I was hooked almost instantly. The concept is phenomenal, the characters were engaging, and the storyline was stellar. It was somewhat like the X-men, but the X-men never seemed like normal people trying to cope with superpowers so much as super people trying to be like normal people. Watching these everyday average people dealing with these new powers that they don't understand and can hardly control really taps into the dream of having such powers yourself. And what person can honestly say they never spent a large portion of their childhood imagining what it would be like to have some superpower or other? (And most of you will probably admit you still do it. Frequently.)
One of the most powerful aspects of that glorious first season was the way that all of the different paths intersected, but it never felt contrived or forced. It seemed like crazy random happenstance that brought their stories into the overall arc and eventually to the amazing finale. Needless to say, I was very excited for the second season.
And then it happened, and things quickly went awry. We have a new villain now that Sylar has been stabbed and is currently out of the picture. Bob, the boring accountant. I don't have much to say about Bob, but he is a completely unconvincing and uninteresting villain. They have also added some new characters, Maya and Alejandro, and nobody gives a shit about them. And if you do give a shit about them, I would love to hear why that is. Hiro (my absolute favorite character from season 1) is trapped in Feudal Japan for more than half of the season on an incredibly slow paced and boring adventure, and then the writers strike hit and we have a ridiculously fast paced wrap up of the mediocre threat.
Now, while season 2 was incredibly disappointing, I was able to forgive it. There was a strike after all, and I have no way of knowing how things would have turned out with an extra ten episodes worth of storytelling. So while I wasn't very excited about season 3 starting, I also wasn't dreading it, and I truly hoped they could write themselves out of the hole created by season 2. Two episodes into the new season and I am very unconvinced. Season 2 involved a lot of the characters acting very much not like what we had come to expect from that first glorious season, and that still seems to be the case.
One of my main problems is that none of these characters have progressed in any meaningful way. Peter is the face of the show, and apparently is setup to be the most heroic of them all (They even feel the need to directly point this out to us in season 3 "Now I know you're lying, nobody is that heroic") but he's still a whiny, neurotic, angsty, and generally useless person. (And if future Peter is any indication, the angst just keeps on comin). Claire has potential with a pretty cool power, but they are going absolutely nowhere with the character, so I'm pretty sure everyone has completely lost interest.
And then we have Hiro. As I mentioned, my personal favorite from season 1 is now one of the characters I hate the most. Our introduction to him this season is him whining about having no great destiny to fill (apparently he doesn't even think saving the world twice is good enough) so he disobeys direct orders from his father, intentionally putting the world at risk, and then repeatedly fucking up every single opportunity he has to put it right. What the hell? He's able to basically single-handedly save the world but can't manage to get anything right? And his whole "I don't trust you Ando because I saw you in the future killing me even though we've already proven a thousand times in this show that the future is always changing" is beyond irritating.
One possible reason why they're having issues actually progressing the characters is because there's so goddamn many of them, and the writers are keen on getting everyone into every episode so we get at most a few minutes on one of the many plot lines before we're unceremoniously transitioned into the middle of another.
My final major issue I'd like to discuss is villains. Early in the life of Heroes I thought the writers had a firm grasp of cool villains. We had Horn Rimmed Glasses man, and Sylar. Both were mysterious, though only Sylar was obviously evil. HRG was pretty ambiguous, but that made him really freakin' cool. They have ruined them both. Now HRG doesn't have anything mysterious to him, and Sylar has been given a back story that makes him a crybaby with mommy issues. They introduced four new villains so far this season, and it took all of three episodes to kill half of them (in really lame ways too).
I have a suspicion that I will continue to watch Heroes, if only because I can see what it could be, although maybe that's why it's so hard for me to accept what it is.